268: What if he followed you into the house?

201: What if you believed it was all your fault?

220: What if they died in your hands?

205: The Long Shadow: What if you processed the remains?

218: What if the family glue came undone?

274: What if you were crushed by 10,000 pounds of stone?

271: Point Blank #3: What if you shielded your students?

276: What if you left your kids held hostage?

197: What if you died?

277: What if you survived the Bosnian genocide?

Season 9 Announcements

289: What if you walked into your high school with a shotgun?

298: What if you were caught in the gears of the machine?

300: What if your boyfriend lit himself on fire? (300th episode)

302: What if you could only find closure within?

303: What if your brother became a monster?

What if you grew up in a violent gang? [Rebroadcast #163]

What if you rescued everyone to save yourself? [Rebroadcast #198]

304: What if you were poisoned?

305: What if you were expected to do no harm?

306: What if you lived someone else’s life?

What if you discovered you were the enemy? [Rebroadcast #230]

What if you spent 15 hours on the edge of sanity? [Rebroadcast #89]

310: What if your mother disappeared?

311: What if you danced for those who couldn’t?

313: What if you had to find your own salvation?

318: What if your daughter went missing?

319: What if you couldn’t find your way home?

275: What if the demons were too large to see?

320: What if your mom believed she was the good witch?

222: What if you were a stranger in your own home?

299: What if your only hope for life was choosing death?

Point Blank: Bonus Interview with Connor Sheets

219: What if you bled to death?

What if you swallowed 48 bags of cocaine? [Rebroadcast #156]

158: What if you entered The Void?

204: The Long Shadow: What if you fought the fire?

223: What if you were the dirty little secret?

207: What if you faced the ultimate betrayal?

194: What if you ran but couldn't hide?

267: What if you were forced to keep the nanny's secret?

307: What if you fell hard for the scam?

321: What if they tried to erase you?

270: Point Blank #2: What if your grandson was orphaned?

232: What if you committed a hate crime?

BONUS Episode - Tyson Was Abducted - from What Was That Like podcast

214: What if you woke up in oblivion?

269: Point Blank #1: What if you pled for your life?

301: What if you were pulled into the abyss?

1: What if your boyfriend lit himself on fire? (1st episode)

309: What if you gave everything to The Job?

202: The Long Shadow: What if you ran the ER five blocks away?

241: What if you were the other woman?

323: What if you were suddenly a blank slate?

The 82 Percent: Bonus Conversation with Alex Chen

What if your cry for help led to an unthinkable tragedy? [Rebroadcast #173]

330: What if your son was murdered at Sandy Hook?

344: What if you spent 7 years in a Thai prison?

What if nine bullets shattered your dreams? [Rebroadcast #240]

What if you ran the ER five blocks away? [Rebroadcast #202]

What if you survived a serial killer? [Rebroadcast #259]

345: What if you were a political hostage in Iran?

347: What if you were held captive in plain sight?

159: What if someone you love committed a monstrous crime?

272: Point Blank #4: What if you made yourself a target?

135: What if a minor procedure left you permanently altered?

278: What if you couldn't keep her safe?

290: What if your husband entered The Void?

312: What if you believed your love could cure him?

314: What if you harbored an unrelenting fury?

198: What if you rescued everyone to save yourself?

233: What if they invaded your home?

322: What if you kept hitting rock bottom?

242: What if you woke up and couldn't move?

195: What if you never stopped searching?

308: What if they couldn’t wake me up?

324: The 82 Percent #1: What if you were asexual?

What if they died in your hands? [Rebroadcast #220]

What if a horrifying loss led to a grand adventure? [Rebroadcast #179]

331: What if you killed the wrong person?

346: What if you risked your freedom to liberate the animals?

Point Blank: Bonus Stories - Jared and James

136: What if you had to fight for your life?

243: What if you signed a billion-year contract?

160: What if you were assaulted by a stranger in the dark?

279: What if you survived online child exploitation?

291: What if your wife had 21 personalities?

315: What if your life became a movie?

199: What if your deepest friendship was your darkest fate?

234: What if your joy came with a tragic price?

196: What if you went missing?

The 82 Percent: Bonus Conversation with Heath Schechinger and Lily Lamboy

The 82 Percent: Podcast Live Event at Mannys

What if you were on the 68th floor? [Rebroadcast #203]

What if you had to relearn who you are?? [Rebroadcast #111]

Happenings Vol. 1: No Man's Land

280: What if you lived on the line between life and death?

235: What if delusion consumed your family?

200: What if you were consumed by your only cure?

292: What if a shocking lie revealed your inner truth?

316: What if a masked man appeared at the foot of your bed?

244: What if you could never make him proud?

273: Point Blank #5: What if you were the sister of the gunman?

Introducing This is Actually Happening

137: What if you were the one to break the silence?

325: The 82 Percent #2: What if you grew up in a polyamorous family?

What if you faced the monster in the mirror? [Rebroadcast #215]

332: What if the worst was yet to come?

Point Blank: Inside the Mind of the Rancho Tehama Gunman

161: What if you suffered a shocking loss?

281: What if you entered the belly of the Narco beast?

236: What if you had the worst roommate ever?

293: What if you believed your son was possessed?

317: What if you found peace in the fog of war?

245: What if you were taken to the dark side?

138: What if at three months pregnant your world was turned upside down?

326: The 82 Percent #3: What if you discovered a new way to love?

What if you couldn't stop shining? [Rebroadcast #189]

333: What if you saw the black mass of death?

162: What if you grew up in a cult?

139: What if your father disappeared?

282: What if you believed you were unlovable?

237: What if your mom hoarded 90 cats?

294: What if you shot your girlfriend?

246: What if you could never be what they wanted?

The 82 Percent: Bonus Conversation with Jessica Fern

334: What if your parachute didn’t open?

295: What if you had to betray your family to save them?

163: What if you grew up in a violent gang?

283: What if you saved your family from annihilation?

238: What if you were tortured in an Iranian prison?

What if you had a ten-year nightmare? [Rebroadcast - #103]

203: The Long Shadow: What if you were on the 68th floor?

247: What if you didn't see the signs?

140: What if you were entangled in a web of shame?

327: The 82 Percent #4: What if you found your family on the path of celibacy?

335: What if you were left for dead?

What if you survived a genocide? [Rebroadcast - #113]

284: What if you found the antidote in the venom?

239: What if a single decision led to a spiral of loss?

141: What if you witnessed a horrific act?

248: What if an invisible disease blew up your life?

164: What if a shocking accusation devastated your family?

296: What if you were haunted by the living and the dead?

328: The 82 Percent #5: What if you were a seahorse dad?

336: What if you escaped a polygamous cult?

249: What if you knew your baby was going to die?

285: What if your life was not your own?

297: What if you were a human jumper cable?

165: What if you were a blind dominatrix?

142: What if it happened in broad daylight?

240: What if nine bullets shattered your dreams?

329: The 82 Percent #6: What if you became your husband’s guardian?

337: What if they delighted in your misery?

250: What if a devastating truth only deepened the mystery?

The Long Shadow: Bonus - Interview with Whit Missildine and Dan Taberski

143: What if you were seduced into a whole new world?

166: What if you didn't have any fear?

286: What if you were born without a hand?

338: What if you thought you got away with it?

287: What if you couldn’t explain his heinous act?

206: What if no one believed you?

251: What if a false allegation stole what you valued most?

144: What if you suffered from postpartum depression?

167: What if you had a fetish for disgust?

339: What if someone gave up everything to save you?

168: What if you believed you were Jesus Christ?

252: What if you watched your mother disappear?

What if a minor procedure left you permanently altered? - [Rebroadcast #135]

288: What if you didn't know you were in a cult?

145: What if your best friend met a tragic fate?

340: What if you kept knocking at death’s door?

253: What if you couldn't even remember the crash?

208: What if you ran through the pain?

169: What if you were an Adult Baby Diaper Lover?

341: What if you had an unquenchable thirst for danger?

254: What if your father annihilated the family?

210: What if you didn't know where they were taking you?

What if you suddenly felt like a werewolf? - [Rebroadcast - #119]

170: What if you didn't sleep for 120 hours?

342: What if you suffered decades of excessive punishment?

211: What if you had to let her go to save yourself?

255: What if they didn't ask and you couldn't tell?

171: What if you saw inside the belly of the beast?

343: What if you were caught in a spiral of violence?

212: What if everyone pretended you were dead?

172: What if you were lured into an unspeakable hell?

256: What if you prepared your boyfriend's body?

146: What if you thought your mother was a robot?

213: What if they were murdered trying to protect you?

147: What if your best friend was dying?

257: What if you didn't know who to believe?

148: What if you killed someone?

258: What if you fell in love with a vampire?

215: What if you faced the monster in the mirror?

149: What if you committed child sexual abuse?

259: What if you survived a serial killer?

150: What if you were trapped in a cycle of abuse?

216: What if you opened Pandora's Box?

173: What if your cry for help led to an unthinkable tragedy?

151: What if he made you think you were crazy?

174: What if you couldn't remember that night?

152: What if you were a human shield?

175: What if you had their knee on your neck?

176: What if you were trapped in a never-ending dream?

260: What if your husband claimed you were dead?

153: What if you wanted to disappear?

177: What if you woke up two months later?

261: What if your mother was a victim of a secret government experiment?

154: What if your mom was murdered by a serial killer?

217: What if you saw the face of death?

155: What if you had to pull the plug?

178: What if you couldn't tell him what really happened?

262: What if you were mauled by a grizzly bear?

179: What if a horrifying loss led to a grand adventure?

263: What if a darkness destroyed your family?

156: What if you swallowed 48 bags of cocaine?

157: What if you couldn't tell anyone?

264: What if you were carjacked at gunpoint?

180: What if your plane was hijacked?

221: What if you were addicted to each other?

265: What if a routine pickup led to a crushing blow?

181: What if you committed a seemingly unforgivable act?

182: What if your daughter committed a seemingly unforgivable act?

266: What if you thought everyone was dead?

183: What if everyone was watching you?

224: What if they stole your childhood?

184: What if you didn't know who he was?

185: What if you kept shaking hands with death?

225: What if you stared into the abyss?

226: What if you had three different faces?

186: What if you were consumed by a preposterous phobia?

187: What if you were trapped all over again?

227: What if you faced a terrifying beast?

188: What if you spent four years inside?

228: What if you grew up with the ghosts of war?

229: What if your life unraveled thread by thread?

189: What if you couldn't stop shining?

190: What if your fairytale was finally within reach?

230: What if you discovered you were the enemy?

191: What if you suffered from trichotillomania?

231: What if they all betrayed you?

192: What if one wrong turn meant life or death?

193: What if your deepest secret was shared with the world?

130: What if you had thoughts of harming those you love most?

131: What if a psychotic break split your life wide open?

132: What if you were kept from the one you loved most?

133: What if your life went up in flames?

134: What if your singular dream fell to pieces?

Introducing: Encounters

Listen Now: We Came to the Forest